Whiskey Cocktails

Five Saints Distilling's Rare Pennsylvania Whiskey is a beloved spirit that's as smooth as it is robust. However, if you're interested in crafting a more personalized whiskey drink for a party or your own personal enjoyment, check out our selection of cocktail recipes!


American Mule Recipe

Five Saints Distillery

  • 1.5 oz WW, dash of bitters, 1/2 oz lime juice, ice and ginger beer into MUG

Country Lemonade Recipe

Five Saints Distillery

  • TG
  • 1.5 oz WW, ice, lemonade

Godmother Recipe

Five Saints Distillery

  • 1.5 oz vodka and 1.5 oz amaretto
  • add to SG, add ice, stir, Top with cherry

Manhattan Recipe

Five Saints Distillery

  • 2 oz Whiskey, 1oz Sweet Vermouth, 2 dashes Ango Bitters, 1 dash orange bitters, no ice, add a cherry (Stir in a Rocks Glass)

Mint Julep Recipe

Five Saints Distillery

  • SHAKER
  • 1.5 oz WW, 1/2 oz simple syrup, 6 mint leaves, ice soda water. Dump all into TG

Old Fashioned "Prohibition" Recipe

Five Saints Distillery

  • 2 oz WW, 1/2 oz simple syrup, 4 dashes of bitters, ice in short glass, STIR, lemon peel rub on rim, drop in and give away

Margarita Recipe

Five Saints Distillery

  • SHAKER
  • 2oz WW, 1 oz triple sec, 1 oz lime juice
  • shake with ice and strain into coupe glass

Whiskey Collins Recipe

Five Saints Distillery

  • TG
  • 1.5 oz WW, 1/2 oz each of lemon juice and simple syrup, ice, club soda

Highball "Humane" Recipe

Five Saints Distillery

  • TG
  • 1.5 oz WW, ice, ginger ale

Whiskey Sour Recipe

Five Saints Distillery

  • SHAKER
  • 1.5 oz WW, 1oz simple syrup, 1/2 oz lemon juice, 1/2 oz lime juice, shake with ice, strain and add to ice in short glass

Old Fashioned "Wisconsin" Recipe

Five Saints Distillery

  • SHAKER
  • 2 oz WW, 1/2 oz simple syrup, 1/4 oz (splash) red vermouth, 4 dash of bitters, orange slice, a cherry, muddle (add WW and ice) shake 10 seconds
  • add to short glass with ice and top off with splash of soda water. Top with orange slice and cherry


What Makes Whiskey a Good Choice for Cocktails?

Whiskey cocktails are an excellent choice for those looking to savor distinct flavors while enjoying a mixed drink. However, what sets whiskey apart from other spirits in cocktails is its versatility and depth — whether you prefer the smooth sweetness of bourbon or the spiciness of rye whiskey, you can create a wide range of delightful flavors.

For example, the classic whiskey sour combines whiskey with fresh lemon juice, simple syrup, and a dash of Angostura bitters to strike a harmonious balance between sweet and sour notes. Whiskey's depth of flavor allows it to stand out in cocktails, making it an ideal base for a variety of mixed drinks, from the minty freshness of a mint julep to the warmth of a hot toddy. To that end, whiskey cocktails can cater to the preferences of whiskey lovers and cocktail enthusiasts alike, making them a favorite choice in the world of mixed drinks.

What Kinds of Food Pair Well With Whiskey Cocktails?

You can elevate a whiskey cocktail by pairing it with complementary foods that enhance the drink's flavors. For instance, the classic combination of a New York sour — made with bourbon or rye whiskey — benefits from the contrast of tangy and savory foods. Whiskey cocktails often pair well with appetizers like cheese and charcuterie, as the whiskey's depth complements the richness of these items.

Spicy rye whiskey cocktails, such as those made with ginger beer, work wonderfully with spicy foods like barbecue. Further, the sweetness of whiskey cocktails with maple syrup or amaretto pairs beautifully with desserts, offering a delightful contrast to the sweetness of treats like pecan pie. Ultimately, the diverse flavor profile of whiskey cocktails ensures there's a suitable pairing for any culinary delight.

What's the Best Glass for Serving Whiskey Cocktails?

Selecting the right glassware can help you serve whiskey cocktails in a way that highlights both their flavors and aesthetics. A rocks glass, also known as an old-fashioned glass, is the preferred vessel for many whiskey cocktails. Its short, wide shape allows for the proper proportion of whiskey to mix and provides ample space for ice and garnishes. The weight and thickness of the glass also contribute to a satisfying drinking experience.

For those who prefer a more refreshing whiskey cocktail, a highball or Collins glass is an excellent choice. These taller glasses are ideal for drinks like whiskey sours and whiskey highballs, accommodating a greater volume of mixer and ice.

Why It's Best to Enjoy Whiskey Cocktails Fresh

Enjoying whiskey cocktails fresh is important if you want to fully appreciate their flavors. The ingredients in whiskey cocktails — such as fresh lemon juice, honey syrup, and spices — are highly susceptible to degradation and oxidation over time. As a result, these cocktails tend to lose their flavor and balance as they sit. Even the carbonation in cocktails like whiskey highballs and whiskey sours from soda water or lemon-lime soda can diminish when the drink is not consumed promptly.

The ice that chills the cocktail can also melt, diluting the flavors in the process. As a result, it's advisable to prepare and enjoy your whiskey cocktails soon after they are made. By doing so, you ensure that each sip is a delightful experience, preserving the integrity and complexity of your favorite whiskey drinks.

Why It's Best to Enjoy Whiskey Cocktails Fresh

Enjoying whiskey cocktails fresh is important if you want to fully appreciate their flavors. The ingredients in whiskey cocktails — such as fresh lemon juice, honey syrup, and spices — are highly susceptible to degradation and oxidation over time. As a result, these cocktails tend to lose their flavor and balance as they sit. Even the carbonation in cocktails like whiskey highballs and whiskey sours from soda water or lemon-lime soda can diminish when the drink is not consumed promptly.

The ice that chills the cocktail can also melt, diluting the flavors in the process. As a result, it's advisable to prepare and enjoy your whiskey cocktails soon after they are made. By doing so, you ensure that each sip is a delightful experience, preserving the integrity and complexity of your favorite whiskey drinks.

To Acquire Whiskey for Your Cocktails, Call Five Saints Distilling Today

Whether you want to craft a classic whiskey cocktail or an innovative cocktail shaker, our Rare Pennsylvania Whiskey will be the perfect base for your concoction. To hear more about our selection of loved spirits and to learn more cocktail ideas, reach out to Five Saints Distilling today.